Reception of the ‘Civilizational State’ Concept in Western Political Science and Politics: From the Image of the ‘Other’ to Self-Identification

In just a decade, Western political thought has gone from using the concept of ‘Civilizational State’ to describe the geopolitical opponents of the modern West to using it in studying the changing political structure and the geopolitical nature of Western civilization itself. These discursive changes demonstrate profound shifts in the paradigmatic perception of both the very structure of international relations and the essence of the actors in these relations. The article presents the results of an analysis of various directions of the civilizational approach in the West, which have an impact in the modern political and scientific discourse of Europe and the United States. The ‘Civilizational State’ is the most appropriate concept to describe the reality of a multipolar world, the transition from the Westphalian model of nation-states to the order of “large spaces” by Carl Schmitt. The reflection of Western political thought on the semantic burden of the concept of ‘Civilizational State’ is obligatory for comprehension in the context of the study of the identity of the Russian Civilizational State — its political, spiritual and social aspects.

References

De Benoist, A. Protiv liberalizma: k Chetvertoi politicheskoi teorii, transl. from French. St. Petersburg: Amfora, 2009.
De Benoist, A. “The Time of the Civilisational States,” Arktos.com, 2023, April 26, URL: https://arktos.com/2023/04/26/the-time-of-the-civilisational-states/
Bettiza, G., Bolton, D., and Lewis, D. “Civilizationism and the Ideological Contestation of the Liberal International Order,” International Studies Review, Vol. 25, No. 2, 2023, URL: https://academic.oup.com/isr/article-pdf/doi/10.1093/isr/viad006/57098582/viad006.pdf
Blond, P. “Empire, Nationalism and Christianity,” Pro Publico Bono — Public Administration, No. 2, 2021, pp. 130–149.
Braudel, F. Material'naia tsivilizatsiia, ekonomika i kapitalizm 15–18 vv.: In 3 vols., transl. L. E. Kubbel', Vol. 3: Vremia mira. Moscow: Progress, 1992.
Brubaker, R. “Between Nationalism and Civilizationism: The European Populist Moment in Comparative Perspective,” Ethnic and Racial Studies, Vol. 40. No. 8, 2017, pp. 1191–1226.
Brzezinski, Z., and Mearsheimer, J. J. “Clash of the Titans: [A Debate],” Foreign Policy, No. 146, 2005, pp. 46–50.
Bunde, T., and Eisentraut, S. “Introduction: Multipolarization,” Munich Security Report 2025: Multipolarization, eds. T. Bunde, S. Eisentraut, and L. Schütte. Munich: Munich Security Conference, 2025, pp. 13–31.
Coker, C. The Rise of the Civilizational State. Cambridge; Medford: Polity Press, 2019.
Culp, W. “Competition with Russia as a ‘Civilization-State’,” Security and Strategy Journal, No. 4, 2024, URL: https://alexanderhamiltonsociety.org/security-strategy/issue-four/competition-with-russia-as-a-civil...
Danilevskii, N. Ia. Rossiia i Evropa. Moscow: Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii, 2008.
Dugin, A. G. “Gosudarstvo-Tsivilizatsiia,” Katehon.com, May 30, 2022, URL: https://katehon.com/ru/article/gosudarstvo-civilizaciya
Dugin, A. G. Revoliutsiia Donal'da Trampa. Moscow: Akademicheskii proekt, 2025.
Egedy, G. “The Civilization State in the War against Ukraine,” Journal of Contemporary Central and Eastern Europe, Vol. 32. No. 2, 2024, pp. 499–512.
Engels, D. Auf dem Weg ins Imperium: Die Krise der Europäischen Union und der Untergang der Römischen Republik. Historische Parallelen. Berlin; München: Europa Verlag, 2014.
Engels, D. “Toleranz und Identität: Rom und Europa im Wandel durch Massenmigration,” Corrigenda, May 3, 2025, URL: https://www.corrigenda.online/kultur/kolumne-von-david-engels-toleranz-und-identitaet-rom-und-europa...
Huntington, S. Stolknovenie tsivilizatsii, transl. T. Velimeev. Moscow: AST, 2014.
Johnson, B. “Only an EU ‘Empire’ Can Secure Liberty: EU Leader,” Acton Institute, September 16, 2019, URL: https://www.acton.org/publications/transatlantic/2019/09/16/only-eu-empire-can-secure-liberty-eu-lea...
Land, N. The Dark Enlightenment. Bad Hersfeld: Imperium Press, 2022.
Maçães, B. The Dawn of Eurasia: On the Trail of the New World Order. New Haven; London: Yale University* Press, 2018.
Maçães, B. “The Attack of the Civilization State,” Noema Magazine, June 15, 2020, URL: https://www.noemamag.com/the-attack-of-the-civilization-state/
Maçães, B. “As Western Liberalism Declines, Civilization States Return,” Noema Magazine, January 31, 2023, URL: https://www.noemamag.com/the-return-of-civilizations/
Marsden, G. M. Understanding Fundamentalism and Evangelicalism. Grand Rapids: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 1991.
McNeill, W. Voskhozhdenie Zapada: Istoriia chelovecheskogo soobshchestva, transl. A. Galushka et al. Kiev: Nika-Tsentr; Moscow: Starklait, 2004.
Milbank, J. “A Tale of Two Monsters and Four Elements: Variations of Carl Schmitt and the Current Global Crisis,” Telos, No. 201, 2022, pp. 127–145.
Norton, B. “What is a ‘Multipolar’ World? China Says Equality; Trump and Marco Rubio Say Imperial Rivalry,” Geopolitical Economy Report, February 16, 2025, URL: https://geopoliticaleconomy.com/2025/02/16/multipolarity-china-trump-marco-rubio-imperialism/
Pabst, A. “China, Russia and the Return of the Civilisational State,” The New Statesman, May 8, 2019, URL: https://www.newstatesman.com/world/2019/05/china-russia-and-the-return-of-the-civilisational-state
Pabst, A. “Renewing the West’s Unique Universalism,” Telos, No. 201, 2022, pp. 165–188.
Pauly, J. “Russia: The Czar’s Gambit,” Munich Security Report 2025: Multipolarization, eds. T. Bunde, S. Eisentraut, and L. Schütte. Munich: Munich Security Conference, 2025, pp. 79–85.
Pye, L. W. The Spirit of Chinese Politics, new ed. Cambridge; London: Harvard University Press, 1992.
Sahlins, M. D. Tribesmen. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall, 1968.
Schmitt, C. Nomos Zemli v prave narodov jus publicum europaeum, transl. K. Loshchevskii, and Iu. Korinets. St. Petersburg: Vladimir Dal', 2008.
Spengler, O. Zakat Evropy. Ocherki morfologii mirovoi istorii, In 2 vols., transl. K. A. Svas'ian, and I. I. Makhan'kov. Moscow: Mysl', 1993–1998.
Thiel, P. “The Straussian Moment,” Politics and Apocalypse, ed. R. Hamerton-Kelly. East Lansing: Michigan State University Press, 2007, pp. 189–218.
Toynbee, A. J. Postizhenie istorii, transl. E. D. Zharkov. Moscow: Airis Press, 2006.
Wallerstein, I. Mir-sistema Moderna, Vol. 1: Kapitalisticheskoe sel'skoe khoziaistvo i istoki evropeiskogo mira-ekonomiki v 16 veke, transl. N. Protsenko, and A. Cherniaev, 2nd ed. Moscow: Universitet Dmitriia Pozharskogo, 2016.
Weaver, R. M. Ideas Have Consequences. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1948.
Yarvin, C. Temnoe prosveshchenie. Amerikanskie konservatory protiv Imperii i Sobora, transl. from Engl. Moscow: Rodina, 2023.
Yilmaz, I., and Morieson, N. “Civilizational Populism Around the World,” European Center for Populism Studies, July 31, 2022, URL: https://www.populismstudies.org/civilizational-populism-around-the-world/
Zhang Weiwei. The China Wave: Rise of a Civilizational State. Singapore: World Century Publishing Corporation, 2012.